The Boston Red Sox have made a habit of making the MVP discussions interesting when they get involved. In 2008, when Dustin Pedroia took home the award, there were many people seemingly including Dusty himself who felt Kevin Youkilis could have easily been named MVP over him. Youk had him in just about every offensive category and had his Gold Glove in 2007 and a great defensive year to match Pedroia's. This year is no different, except there is a third player added into the mix.
Once again, Dustin Pedroia will find himself in the MVP discussions. After a slow start, he has been on fire hitting over .350 since June to bring his average up to around the .310 mark. He has an eevn .400 OBP with 17 more walks then strikeouts (73/56). With 16 home runs and 23 steals, Pedroia also seems destined for the 20/20 club.To my knowledge, there hasn't been a 2B to join the 20/20 club since Roberto Alomar in 2001. Alomar came in 4th in MVP voting that year with a .336 average and a Gold Glove. With the monster July that Pedroia had, he seemed destined to match and surpass these numbers. While it now seems like his season may not match Alomar's best when it's all said and done, voters will have a hard time ignoring what Pedroia has done in 2011.
And then there is Jacoby Ellsbury. There was a lot of banter in the last 18 months or so about how the Red Sox should have traded Ellsbury when they had the chance. Many thought a decline was imminent after his injuries in 2010, and the Sox missed out by not moving him for a superstar arm when they had the chance. Well, let's just say Theo Epstein is doing a happy dance that he was able to hold back on moving the dynamic young star. Jacoby has already joined the 20/20 club, a feat that I don't think even the best of experts expected he would accomplish so early in his career if at all. With 20 home runs, 31 steals, 31 doubles, 85 runs scored and an astouding 74 RBIs out of the lead-off spot, Jacoby is my favorite pick for the MVP this year. He is in the top 3 on the best scoring team in baseball in every category except RBI's (4th) and walks (5th). He had over a .900 OPS for a short period of time and has sat comfortably just under for most of the season. The only downsides to Jacoby are his CS (11) and his plate discipline. His strikeout totals are up on his career numbers, but not a concerning amount. He is an aggressive hitter and that has benefit him in 2011.
Finally, there is the man who we all expected to be the AL MVP before the season even began. Adrian Gonzalez has a video game type line (.352/.412/.552) but there is only one reason I give him the MVP. That reason is consistency. When the offense is slumping or the pitching is off, Adrian Gonzalez has still been on. Despite his power outage since the All-Star break, A-Gon is still hitting .347/.406/.442 in the second half. Gonzalez will likely be the AL MVP, but he can be sure Bautista and Granderson won't make it easy.
Jose Bautista has had a bit of a falloff. This comes to no surprise for 3 reasons. The first of these is that his numbers were too good to be true. I don't doubt now, that Beast-tista as I've called him all year in 2011, is the real deal. This guy is going to hit .300 and 35-50 home runs every year for the duration of his 5-year deal in Toronto. However, this is a guy who has maintained for portions of the season over a 1.200 OPS. If not for the surge by Mark Teixiera, he had dozens more home runs in the last 2 years then the next guy in line. Numbers like those if your name is not Ted Williams are unsustainable, I don't care who you are. He still has an amazing .311/.448/.636 line for a 1.084 OPS. Those numbers have been dropping fast however, as he is having a rough August hitting just .205 with 3 home runs, and amazingly for the first month all season, more strikeouts then walks. The reason for this falloff, is that the break and the Home Run Derby tend to throw off guys' strokes and timing. Many players take a long time to get back in a rhythm, even great ones like Bautista and Gonzalez. There is also the minor injury he sustained against the Yankees. Just another thing thrown in there right around the All-Star break that could effect his timing and swing. All of these things may keep the MVP from him.
Curtis Granderson meanwhile, is making a late push into the talks. Overtaking a lead Adrian Gonzalez has held all season, Curtis Granderson drove in his 93rd run, putting a new face on the leaderboard for the first time since May. Since the break, Granderson has hit .291 bringing his season average up to .275. He also has 107 runs scored (1st), 33 HR (2nd), and 22 steals. He has taken his play to the next level in 2011, and while he won't win a Gold Glove in CF, he has made some spectacular plays and even a Red Sox fan must admit this guy can be one of the most exciting to watch in the game. Another true 5-tool player.
So who is your pick for the 2011 American League MVP? This year is going to have a lot of tough award choices with the Cy Young also very debatable.